
How to Build a High-Performance Culture: Why Leadership Behaviours Matter
On this page
On this page
- Executive summary
- What creates a high-performance culture?
- Further listening: Leadership and high-performance environments
- Culture is shaped by everyday behaviours
- Care means recognising what people need
- Clarity gives people direction
- High standards require challenge and accountability
- Different perspectives help identify what leaders might miss
- Curiosity and continuous evolution
- Five questions every leader should consider
- Final thoughts
- Research and further reading
Executive summary
A high-performance culture develops through the behaviours, expectations and relationships that people experience every day. Leaders have a significant influence on that environment through the standards they establish, the clarity they provide and the way they support and challenge those around them.
Drawing on 15 years working in professional football, this article explores the importance of genuine care for individuals, consistent organisational direction, accountability, collaboration across departments and continuous improvement. These principles are supported by research examining the relationship between leadership behaviours, team effectiveness, employee wellbeing and adaptability.
A central theme is the importance of consistency. Creating a strong culture requires leaders to demonstrate these behaviours throughout the organisation, particularly during periods of pressure, uncertainty and change.
What creates a high-performance culture?
Having spent 15 years working in professional football, I've been fortunate to work alongside some exceptional people. Different managers, coaches, practitioners and support staff, each bringing their own experiences, expertise and approaches to performance. I've also experienced significant organisational transformations, with varying degrees of success, which have shaped my understanding of leadership and the environments that allow people to perform at their best.
You can bring together outstanding individuals across every department, invest in excellent facilities and have access to considerable amounts of information, yet none of that guarantees success. How people work together, the clarity of their direction, the standards they maintain and their willingness to challenge one another all influence the quality of what an organisation delivers.
Throughout my career, I've become increasingly conscious of the importance of care, clarity, connection, challenge and curiosity, supported by a shared commitment to improvement. These principles have developed through experience, and many have parallels in research examining leadership, team effectiveness and workplace wellbeing.
Further listening: Leadership and high-performance environments
I explored several of these principles in more detail during my conversation on the Empowering Leaders podcast, including the importance of clarity, connection and creating environments where people can continue developing.
Listen to the conversation: A Peek Behind the Curtain of Arsenal's Transformation
Culture is shaped by everyday behaviours
Most organisations have defined values, expectations and ambitions. These provide a useful starting point, although their influence ultimately depends on how consistently they are reflected in everyday behaviours. The way decisions are made, how mistakes are handled, whether people feel comfortable challenging an opinion and how leaders respond when performance falls below expectations all contribute to the environment people experience.
In professional football, the pressure to perform is constant. There is always another match approaching, decisions need to be made quickly and performance is continually assessed. Within that environment, I became increasingly aware of how closely people observe the behaviour of those leading them. The way a leader responds to a disappointing result, handles disagreement or supports somebody who is struggling can influence how the wider group behaves in similar situations.
These interactions become particularly important over time. People develop an understanding of which behaviours are encouraged, which are challenged and which are allowed to continue. If a leader consistently demonstrates the standards they expect from others, those expectations become more credible. When there is a significant difference between what leaders say and what they do, maintaining those standards becomes much more difficult.
Research examining leadership behaviours and team performance provides support for the importance of these interactions. A 2021 systematic review by O'Donovan and colleagues examined the relationship between leadership behaviours and healthcare team performance, identifying positive associations between empowering and relationship-focused leadership and several team outcomes. Although the findings come from healthcare settings, they provide useful insight into environments where specialists must coordinate their expertise while managing demanding responsibilities.
For me, the practical implication is that leaders need to be conscious of the behaviours they demonstrate every day. Culture develops through repeated experiences, and consistency in leadership behaviour helps people understand what the organisation expects from them.
Care means recognising what people need
Care has become one of the most important principles in my approach to leadership. I've always believed that if you're going to ask a great deal of someone, you should also take a genuine interest in them as an individual. This involves understanding their circumstances, recognising what motivates them and being aware of the occasions when they may need additional support.
One behaviour that has always stood out to me is how frequently people ask somebody how they are without giving them a genuine opportunity to respond. There is a considerable difference between asking "How are you?" while continuing to walk down a corridor and stopping to ask the same question while giving someone your full attention. The words may be identical, but the interaction is very different. Taking that extra moment demonstrates that you're interested in the response and prepared to listen.
These everyday interactions contribute to the relationships leaders develop with their staff. When you understand people well, you may begin to recognise changes in their behaviour, energy or engagement that suggest something isn't quite right. They may be experiencing difficulties outside work, struggling with their responsibilities or finding the demands placed upon them more challenging than usual.
Recognising these situations is an important part of leadership, although it requires judgement. Sometimes an individual needs reassurance, encouragement or an arm around the shoulder. On other occasions, they may benefit from adjustments to their workload, practical assistance or time away from work. The appropriate response will depend on their circumstances, and it is important to discuss what support they want rather than make assumptions about their needs.
Leaders also need to recognise that they won't see everything themselves. Having trusted people around them who understand the workforce can help identify concerns that might otherwise be overlooked. This requires an environment where colleagues feel comfortable raising concerns appropriately, while respecting the privacy and independence of the individual involved. There will also be circumstances where support from qualified health or occupational health professionals is required.
Research provides some support for the relationship between leadership behaviours and employee wellbeing. A 2022 literature review by Lundqvist and colleagues examined studies of leadership and wellbeing across Nordic workplaces, identifying recurring associations between supportive leadership and positive employee outcomes. The authors also highlighted the importance of leaders being available and providing people with appropriate space, while recognising that working conditions influence these relationships.
Similarly, a 2023 scoping review by Czakert and Berger explored the relationship between leadership, employees' experiences outside work and wellbeing. The review highlighted the importance of considering how leadership can influence the resources people have available to manage demands and recover.
From my perspective, creating an environment where people can perform consistently involves understanding the demands they're facing and recognising when support may be needed. That understanding develops through genuine relationships and regular conversations. It also requires leaders to be approachable enough that people feel able to raise difficulties themselves.
Clarity gives people direction
I've experienced two significant organisational transformations during my career. One was successful, while the other was considerably less so. There were numerous factors involved in both situations, but when I reflect on the differences between them, clarity stands out as one of the most important.
In the successful transformation, there was a clear understanding of where the organisation wanted to go and what it was trying to achieve. Those leading the organisation communicated that direction consistently throughout their tenure, allowing staff to understand the expectations placed upon them and how their responsibilities contributed to the wider objectives. This consistency enabled departments to align their decisions and develop their work within an established direction.
Clarity alone didn't create success. The quality of the people involved, their commitment, the resources available and numerous other factors all contributed. However, having a shared understanding of the direction provided a foundation that allowed those different elements to work together.
The contrasting experience was very different. There was a lack of clarity around the organisation's direction, accompanied by frequent changes in expectations and priorities. This made it difficult for staff to establish a consistent understanding of what they were being asked to deliver. Individuals could invest considerable time and effort into work that was subsequently deprioritised, while departments found themselves continually adjusting to changing requirements.
Over time, this can become frustrating and make it difficult to establish momentum. People may be working hard and demonstrating considerable expertise, but without a consistent direction, their efforts can become disconnected from the wider organisation.
Of course, organisations must be prepared to adapt. Circumstances change, new information becomes available and priorities sometimes need to shift. What matters is whether leaders can explain those changes, maintain an understanding of the broader objectives and help people recognise how their responsibilities fit into the evolving direction.
I also learned that clarity needs to exist throughout an organisation. It is of limited value for the senior leadership team to understand the ambition if those responsible for delivering it receive inconsistent messages. Different roles will require different levels of detail, but everyone should have an understanding of what matters and how their contribution supports the wider objectives.
A 2024 systematic review by Friman and colleagues examined leadership characteristics associated with quality management in healthcare organisations. Strategic, communicative, supportive and participatory leadership were among the characteristics identified. While the research concerns healthcare quality management, it provides a useful perspective on the importance of combining organisational direction with effective communication and staff involvement.
My experience of these two transformations reinforced how much clarity can influence an organisation's ability to make progress. When people understand where they're going and receive consistent messages from those leading them, they are better placed to apply their expertise, make decisions and contribute towards shared objectives.
High standards require challenge and accountability
I've always believed that leaders should be capable of caring deeply about people while maintaining demanding expectations. High standards require people to understand their responsibilities and recognise when their performance or behaviour needs to improve. Supporting development also involves being prepared to address situations that are uncomfortable or difficult.
In demanding environments, there will inevitably be occasions when someone falls below the standards expected of them. They may not have delivered a particular responsibility, demonstrated the required behaviour or performed at the level they are capable of achieving. Avoiding those situations can create problems, particularly when other individuals are consistently meeting their responsibilities and begin to question whether expectations are being applied fairly.
The way leaders respond to these situations is important. Someone struggling because they lack knowledge, experience or appropriate support may require a very different response from an individual who understands the expectations but repeatedly fails to meet them. Taking time to understand the circumstances allows the conversation to focus on what needs to change and how improvement can be supported.
Accountability should also extend to those in leadership positions. Leaders need to demonstrate the same commitment to standards that they expect from others, including accepting responsibility when decisions haven't produced the intended outcome. Being prepared to acknowledge mistakes, seek feedback and adjust your approach helps establish an environment where accountability is shared rather than imposed in one direction.
Research examining leadership behaviours provides support for considering both the task and interpersonal aspects of leadership. The systematic review by O'Donovan and colleagues (2021) identified relationships between different leadership approaches and team outcomes, although the findings also highlight the complexity of determining which behaviours are most effective across different situations.
For me, consistency remains particularly important. People should understand what is expected, why those standards matter and how concerns will be addressed. They should also have confidence that expectations are applied fairly and that the purpose of accountability is to maintain performance and support improvement.
Different perspectives help identify what leaders might miss
One of the most valuable lessons I've taken from working in professional football is the importance of bringing different perspectives together. Modern organisations contain individuals with considerable specialist knowledge, and their expertise should influence decisions. However, even experienced people can become focused on the challenges and assumptions within their own areas, which makes contributions from other departments particularly valuable.
An approach I've found useful is encouraging people from across the organisation to identify areas where they believe improvements could be made, regardless of whether those areas sit within their own department. Someone working in one part of the business may recognise an inefficiency, opportunity or emerging problem that those directly involved have become accustomed to or haven't considered from the same perspective.
Giving people this opportunity encourages them to think about the organisation beyond their immediate responsibilities. It can also reveal potential blind spots in the information reaching senior leaders. As responsibilities increase, it becomes harder to maintain a detailed understanding of everything happening across an organisation, and the perspectives you receive may become increasingly influenced by the people you interact with most frequently.
The next stage is equally important. Bringing the individuals who have suggested improvements together with relevant leaders creates an opportunity to discuss their ideas, understand the rationale behind them and determine whether practical changes are possible. It also exposes people to discussions and decisions they might not ordinarily be involved in, providing opportunities for their own development.
Where appropriate, individuals can be given responsibility for helping to develop or implement their suggestions. This encourages ownership and allows people to see how their contribution may influence the wider organisation. Even when an idea isn't taken forward, explaining the reasons behind that decision demonstrates that the contribution has been considered.
I've found that these conversations can provide leaders with valuable information while helping staff develop a stronger understanding of the wider business. They can also create connections between departments that might otherwise have limited opportunities to collaborate.
A 2024 meta-analysis by Bonini and colleagues, involving research with more than 11,000 participants, identified a positive relationship between leadership and adaptive performance. The authors also highlighted the influence of contextual factors and the nature of the work, recognising the importance of understanding which approaches are appropriate in different environments.
The practical value of encouraging different perspectives is something I've seen throughout my career. Each department may have a well-reasoned position based on its own expertise, yet the organisation still needs to consider how those perspectives fit together.
Every department can be right and the organisation can still make the wrong decision.
Effective leadership requires bringing that information together, recognising what may be missing and helping people make decisions that serve the organisation as a whole.
Curiosity and continuous evolution
Curiosity has played an important role throughout my career. When I first started working in professional football, I wanted to gain as much experience as possible, taking opportunities to learn about different disciplines, accept new responsibilities and put myself in situations outside my comfort zone.
A significant part of that development came from people who were prepared to give me opportunities. They shared their knowledge, challenged my thinking and trusted me with responsibilities that allowed me to grow. Those experiences helped me understand different aspects of performance and appreciate how much there was still to learn.
I believe that willingness to learn becomes increasingly important as people move into senior leadership positions. Experience provides a valuable foundation for making decisions, but no individual can have a complete understanding of every challenge facing an organisation. Being prepared to seek different perspectives, question established approaches and recognise gaps in your own knowledge remains important regardless of seniority.
This becomes particularly relevant when an organisation achieves success. Positive results can reinforce confidence in existing approaches, and understanding what has contributed to that success is valuable. However, the environment around an organisation continues to change. Competitors improve, technology develops, people move on and new challenges emerge.
Organisations therefore need to continue evolving, even when their current approach is delivering results. That evolution should be considered rather than driven by a desire for constant change. Understanding which principles and behaviours have contributed to success allows an organisation to preserve what remains valuable while identifying areas that need to develop.
The 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis by Bonini and colleagues identified a positive association between leadership and adaptive performance, highlighting the contribution of relational and motivational factors and the importance of context. These findings provide useful support for the value of leadership approaches that encourage people to respond constructively to changing demands.
From my experience, organisations benefit when curiosity and improvement are encouraged throughout the workforce. People should feel able to suggest new ideas, learn from outcomes and challenge processes that may no longer be appropriate. Leaders also need to provide opportunities for individuals to develop their knowledge and take on new challenges, just as others did for me during the early stages of my career.
Successful organisations have much to learn from their achievements, but continued success requires an awareness of what may need to change. Maintaining that curiosity is an important part of staying competitive.
Five questions every leader should consider
The research and experiences discussed throughout this article raise several questions that I believe are useful for leaders to revisit regularly.
1. Do I genuinely understand how my people are doing? Am I taking the time to build relationships, recognise when individuals may be struggling and provide appropriate support?
2. Can people clearly explain where we're going? Do staff understand the organisation's direction, the standards expected and how their responsibilities contribute to wider objectives?
3. Am I applying standards consistently? Are expectations fair and clear, and am I prepared to address difficult situations while helping people improve?
4. Whose perspective am I missing? Am I creating opportunities for people outside the usual decision-making group to contribute ideas, identify blind spots and challenge existing approaches?
5. Are we continuing to evolve? Are we learning from our experiences, creating development opportunities and adapting to new challenges, including when things are going well?
These questions can be useful starting points for reflection, particularly when an organisation is experiencing change or struggling to maintain consistent performance.
Final thoughts
Throughout my career, I've been fortunate to experience different leadership approaches, significant organisational transformations and demanding performance environments. Those experiences have shaped my belief that the environment created by leaders has a considerable influence on what individuals and organisations can achieve.
Providing clarity, understanding people's needs, maintaining high standards and creating opportunities for different perspectives to contribute all require consistent attention. Leaders must also remain open to learning and recognise that the demands facing their organisations will continue to change.
I have increasingly come back to one principle when considering the environment I want to help create:
Clarity creates the conditions. Connection creates commitment. Curiosity creates improvement.
The responsibility of leadership is to demonstrate those principles consistently, creating an environment where people understand what matters, feel supported and are given the opportunity to perform at their best.
Research and further reading
- O'Donovan, R., et al. (2021). A Systematic Review Exploring the Impact of Focal Leader Behaviours on Healthcare Team Performance. Journal of Nursing Management. https://doi.org/10.1111/jonm.13403
- Lundqvist, D., Wallo, A., & Reineholm, C. (2022). Leadership and Well-being of Employees in the Nordic Countries: A Literature Review. Work. https://doi.org/10.3233/WOR-210063
- Czakert, J. P., & Berger, R. (2023). The Influence of Leadership on Employees' Work–Nonwork Interface and Wellbeing: A Scoping Review. Current Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-023-04762-3
- Friman, S., et al. (2024). The Characteristics of Leadership and Their Effectiveness in Quality Management in Healthcare. Health Services Management Research. https://doi.org/10.1177/09514848241254921
- Bonini, A., Panari, C., Caricati, L., & Mariani, M. G. (2024). The Relationship Between Leadership and Adaptive Performance: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. PLOS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0304720
About P1 ELEVEN
P1 Eleven brings experience from high-performance sport into executive performance, combining practical expertise, scientific research and personalised performance intelligence.
Discover P1 Eleven Executive to learn more about our approach to supporting performance, health and wellbeing.



